I have 3 pairs of Audio Nirvana drivers:
- 12 inch SCF Alnico's - mounted in big bass-reflex boxes
- 15 inch SCF ferrites - mounted in OB's
- 12 inch SCF ferrites - inventory waiting for a project
In an OB design, the sonic difference between the Audio Nirvana Alnico's and ferrites almost needs to be A/B'd to detect differences. If you put them in a box, as suggested by Audio Nirvana's owner... the differences become more apparent. They all make bass in boxes, more than I ever expected. In a reasonable sized OB, they are a bit thin in the bottom and need lower frequency augmentation IMO.
I have heard my 15 ferrite drivers in a 8.0 cu.ft. box and in an OB. The driver's mids/highs are noticeably smoother and more natural in the OB. However, the 8.0 box(obtained from the previous owner) was far less than optimally constructed or damped. Dampening is
critical in a box to get the most from these driver's.
The 12 Alnico's I have in a 5.6 cu.ft. box of AN's David Dicks recommendation/design. I have paid special attention and tuning to the boxes internal dampening and structural design of the box. This setup is full-range in every sense of the word, except subwoofer realm bass. But in the mid-bass weight region, they are actually a little heavy - but I like this, as it puts meat-on-the-bones and imparts a very nice warmth to most of the music I like to listen to. Standup bass is "in the room".
This is a bit of speculation on my part, but I have heard Randy's Betsy baffles... as best as acoustic memory can serve, I would say the AN Alnico's are a little more like Betsy's in the upper frequencies, where as the ferrite AN's are a little "hotter" like most full-range drivers in the upper mids on up.
I would suggest to anyone wanting to dip their toes into OB's and Audio Nirvana's to go with a ferrite model to start with - even shop around for some used. New, the ferrite models are 1/2 price or less of the Alnico models and will give you a very good taste of what can be achieved. If you like what you hear, and want to go all-in long term, then spring for the Alnico's. I might be willing to part with some of my AN driver's. Not because I don't like them -
the exact opposite - I would just upgrade to bigger, newer, Alnico AN models - I'm a believer - full-range xoverless is it for me, as long as you pair with the right amp.