willbur6
|
Just got my Torii V and made me realize I didn't have a great handle on the distinction between push-pull and class A/B. I asked AI to help me out with understanding this. How do you think it did?
Q: can you explain the distinction between amplifiers using class a vs class a/b and amplifiers using single-ended vs push-pull topologies in a way that is simple to understand that uses analogies to more mechanical situations?
A: To understand the difference between amplifier classes and topologies, it is helpful to think of the audio signal as a heavy wheel that needs to be spun in two directions (forward and backward) to create sound.
1. Class A vs. Class AB (Bias/Efficiency) This distinction is about how hard the engine is running at all times. Class A (The Racing Engine): Imagine a car engine that stays at 8,000 RPM even when the car is stopped at a red light. It is always ready to deliver full power instantly. Mechanical Analogy: Because the engine never "rests," it is incredibly smooth and responsive (low distortion), but it gets extremely hot and wastes a massive amount of fuel (energy) even when you aren't moving. Class AB (The Modern Daily Driver): This engine idles quietly at a stoplight. It stays "warm" so it can move quickly, but it doesn't work at full tilt until you step on the gas. Mechanical Analogy: It is much more efficient and runs cooler. However, there is a tiny, almost imperceptible "stutter" as the engine transitions from idling to accelerating (known as crossover distortion).
2. Single-Ended vs. Push-Pull (Topology/Layout) This distinction is about how many "workers" are moving the wheel. Single-Ended (The One-Armed Cyclist): One single transistor or tube is responsible for the entire wave. Imagine a cyclist using only one leg to pedal. Mechanical Analogy: To get the pedal back up, the cyclist relies on the momentum of the bike or a heavy spring. This creates a very "organic" and fluid motion, but it is physically limited in how much power it can generate before the leg gets tired. Push-Pull (The Two-Person Saw): Two transistors work as a team. One "pushes" the positive half of the sound wave, and the other "pulls" the negative half. Mechanical Analogy: Think of two people on opposite ends of a crosscut saw. As one person pushes, the other pulls. This is incredibly powerful and efficient, allowing you to cut through much larger logs (drive bigger speakers), but the hand-off between the two people must be perfectly timed to avoid a "jerk" in the motion.
Summary of Combinations Class A Single-Ended: A single worker constantly running at 100% effort. Purest sound, very low power, very high heat. Class A Push-Pull: Two workers both running at 100% effort, handing off the task. More power than single-ended, but still very hot. Class AB Push-Pull: Two workers who "rest" when the saw is moving away from them and "work" when it's their turn to pull. This is the most common design because it provides high power and efficiency with very high-quality sound.
|