
The distorted understanding part almost sounds like a lead in to a geeky joke!
If you're only turning your amp about 25%, then you probably have a lot of headroom and are fine with the amp you have. Ask yourself, does it sound like it's having trouble keeping up with complex music? If not, then do like Lon suggests, and focus on your sources.
You didn't mention your speakers, so I'm assuming you're not looking to replace them.
Make sure all the links in your chain are good - interconnects, power cords, speaker lines etc.
And of course, I'm always a big proponent of room treatment. Get some bass traps, absorbers, and diffusers in there!