I think it was Dick Olsher... that wrote an article and routinely talks about bass "weight". And of course it is absolutely impacted to great extent by room interaction... but once you "hear it".. it's hard to live without it - it just adds so much to the realism of playback.
My current room is "huge"... practically an anechoic chamber. In fact, it's too dead in some regards. No detectable, by ear, slap echo at all.
I heard the HSU mid-bass modules at RMAF in HSU's room there. Well... an empty, standard size hotel room - not ideal for nearly anything without lots of treatment. I have never had a pair of them in my listening room, but suspect they might actually be what most people are yearning for - they just don't know it - so they add subs and then try to run them at higher xover points than they were designed for, which isn't ideal in most cases.
Lon... completely understand your point of reference. I have a 7-piece drum kit in another part of the man-cave... I still haven't managed a system that can fool me into thinking I'm listening to the real thing... but I'm getting closer....
no replacement for "displacement" you know!
I will try to take some pics and post of my Audio Nirvana DIY's... they are not quite where I want them to be
cosmetically - yet. Still a bit of a work-in-progress there. This was my very first attempt at "finish" woodworking skills... but they're not horrid either.
Zygi would laugh at me and make me feel bad! But functionally and sonically, after a couple months of listening to them now, I think they are "there". However, I want to make it clear that my sonic conclusion here, is
only applicable when they are driven by my Torii MkIII. There may be other amps that have this synergy and magic with the crossoverless, high-efficiency, full range types... but I haven't found it or heard it yet. And that includes the Decware SE34i I had before the Torii. The SE34 is beautiful sounding, but the Torii is logic defying, revolutionary and life altering with these drivers.
I don't have the "
added ambiance" of an HR-1, or an ERR or an open baffle type with these. But I do think that sonic trait is indeed "additive" - but I find I "like it" also - at least part of the time. Which led me to my 2nd DIY speaker project(custom Hawthorne Audio Trios-OB's), which won't be completed until after Zenfest. Then, maybe, just maybe, I will be "there" and satisfied for awhile. Probably only a little while, but hopefully the audiophile nervosa will be put in check for at least a few months. Oh.. wait a minute, I forgot about that Torii MK.IV upgrade thing looming just around the corner... OK... maybe after that..!!!
