Fireblade
Seasoned Member
  

Knowledge comes, but wisdom lingers. A.L.Tennyson
Posts: 1046
|
Ok, maybe I didn't express the ideas clear enough (or maybe I'm wrong). Also, don't take what I'm about to say as criticism of any kind:
The adjustable negative feedback 'IS' a tradeoff by design. It trades midrange liquidity and lush for more powerful dynamics. I did not assume this. It's a nice feature for someone interested in applying this tradeoff to accomodate recording sound characteristics. I'm just saying, I would not consider it after some thought, for the stated reasons.
You can argue about design proess and I agree, but adding a negative feedback selector in the signal path may, ceteris paribus, not be without a cost. In this case, the user will trade some midrange sonics (or stability, or something), for the added boost in dynamics. That's inherent in negative feedback as a design choice.
I'm not implying Decware did this just to show off, but to allow interested people to take advantage of this possibility. To show the dynamic potential of a well designed beam-tetrode SE amp. If 'I' was buying the new model, that additional cost would not be put to use, is what I'm saying.
Finally, I keep listening to contradictory believes in this forum re the sonic differences between some design philosophies: As an example, I was reminded here of the 'special' sound of the simplest amp, the SE84C+, in terms of its liquidity and 'magic.' I agree. So, there are differences and tradeoffs in any design, given the objectives pursued.
In this case, having the means to affect the final sound signature throughout the discrete negative feedback range, is good. I just would probably not use it as I would not sacrifice, again, any of the already possible midrange or other (liquidity, etc.) characteristics in the Mini at the 'voiced' optimal negative feedback level, just for the added dynamic boost.
That's my amp's usage choice, based on my current opinion, until someone proves me wrong. The 'prove me wrong' is what I was asking for as feedback. I'm a rational individual, I believe in logic and facts. I may be missing enough information, but I have not seen it yet.
I'm all for the Caps upgrade, though, definitely.
Thanks for the inputs.
|