Fireblade
Seasoned Member
  

Knowledge comes, but wisdom lingers. A.L.Tennyson
Posts: 1046
|
Florida Boy,
Excuse my lack of experience. I just thought there would be a tradeoff in terms of circuit dynamics when going for tubes that are at the limits of the original design. In other words, the amp has been tunned for 6V6's, and even though it can accept related different families of tubes, sometimes these require different current ratings and such, which make me wonder what tradeoffs are involved.
Is it tube life span, or for example early aging of insulators and other components due to higher heat dissipation, or maybe reduced headroom given output transformers reaching their ceiling sooner with more current demanding tubes, etc.?
Something has to give in, since the original design is optimized/voiced around the 6V6 tube. Although the transformers, for example, are designed with high redundancy, ceteris paribus their capacity limits would be reached sooner with more demanding tubes, at least in my view, with possible headroom being reduced before clipping, etc.
How do we know, for example, if the tiny specd coupling capacitors or some other components in the topology are comfortable and non vulnerable to still compatible yet extreme output tubes?
If I were to choose a set of alternate tubes, I would use the ones that best sounded in my system, but chosen from those closer in their specification and general behavior to the 6V6. Or, conversely, learn what would be the logical adjustments in the circuit to optimize it for the different demands involved in tubes behaving more radically than the 6V6s in this particular circuit design.
What about rectifiers, input drivers, etc.? Aren't some of these prone to react differently to some more demanding conditions?
These are all intuitive and logical questions I ask myself when considering tube rolling. The ideal setup, again, should not be at the expense of some possible inadvertent tradeoff that may trigger possible failure scenarios or shorter lifespans from the gear.
I would just like to learn how to address these concerns. And, yes, I've noted the Valvo 350 B as one of the good alternatives for the post break-in stage, but would feel much more comfortable understanding the expected effects these may pose to that circuit's behavior.
|