You didnt specify if it was a square or round Kicker solo baric. The whole product number would help too, the L7 differs from the L5 in characteristics.
Generally, the Kickers Solo Barics go real loud, bit muddy(low SQ, high SPL), and suited more toward large ported enclosures.
The JL 12W3 is more efficient (less power for more volume) goes loud and reputedly can sound very clean in the right enclosure and works well in a small sealed box. I dont know that you would need 2 of these in your single cab silverado

unless you wanna be deaf in the near future? - !unless! - because they would be mounted isobaric (coupled) you could sacrifice the sealed chamber volume in the DB box. Direct coupling (isobaric) effectively halves the required volume as would be used for the 1 driver.
This could save you some room in your cab!
Has anyone else done this?The DBK box designs are essentially a tuneable 4th order bandpass box, which is somewhere between a sealed and ported boxes for the suited driver characteristics. (talking driver Q's)
I would be leaning toward using the JL woofer.
Other thing; is the Kicker (if a square 12") too big to fit in the DBK212 box?