Welcome, Guest. Please Login or Register
Decware Audio Forums
07/18/19 at 12:03:27 


       



Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print
ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete (Read 3789 times)
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #50 - 06/11/19 at 01:26:02
 
Wondering if any of you folks have experienced this.

It seems to me that different periods - 15 minutes to 45 minutes - before starting to play music makes a difference in quality of sound output v/s background noise.

Playing music immediately after powering up was the worst scenario. It took about 2 hours to get that exquisite sound. So the shortest period to run the ZMA idle is about 15 minutes.

Looks to me that if the ZMA is left powered up but silent for about 15 to 20 minutes before beginning to play music caused the background noise level to be pitch black and music to be fabulous straight off the bat.

Interestingly if the ZMA was charged up for 45 minutes or more before starting to play music, the background appears to be ever so slightly less black than those experienced at the above shorter time. But now the speed increased to perfection and the music playback is better than fabulous – floating and realistic.

I have been deeply thinking why this is so. My thinking is that it is because there is no dedicated noise filter arrangement in the power supply of the ZMA but there is reliance on noise damping instead, in those large capacitors. So at the 15 -20 minute mark the massive caps are still not fully charged as yet and any ripple riding on the power supply after the rectifies get absorbed by the capacitors because there is slack in the capacitors to dampen the noise riding on the power supply. Where as at the 45 minute mark onwards the caps are fully charged and so some of the power line ripple simply bypass the fully charged caps and move on further down the circuit but now the fully charged capacitors far more readily supply current.

My preference is the fully charged state as it produces music that is just fantastically timed and detailed, the very minor increase in background level is not at all normally perceptible unless highly concentrating on it only with single mindedness, blocking all else.

I would imagine for stock ZMAs without massive amounts of capacitance the times would be proportionally less but in any case leaving the ZMA powered up for at least about 5 to 10 minutes before starting to actually play your music would yield the best results. Otherwise depending on how hard and what is being played it would take longer to reach that optimum point.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Archie
Seasoned Member
****




Posts: 1417
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #51 - 06/11/19 at 01:31:10
 
Are you saying that NOT playing music is required?  Or will it catch up eventually if music is played from the start?
Back to top
 
 

Technics 1200G TT w/ Ortofon Jubilee MC cart
ZMC1
ZP3 (25th A Mods)
ZR2 (25th A Mods)
CSP3 (25th A mods)
ZMA (25th A mods)
HR1s (Upgrd - top & bass drivers & X-ovr)
Silver Cabling
DIY Isolation platforms under everything.
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #52 - 06/11/19 at 03:45:01
 
I mean just turning the ZMA "ON" without actually driving the speakers. i.e. the source e.g. DAC etc is paused or off. Driving the speakers causes a draw  of power from the amp delaying the large capacitors from being fully charged.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Archie
Seasoned Member
****




Posts: 1417
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #53 - 06/11/19 at 15:53:13
 
Got it.  Thanks.
Back to top
 
 

Technics 1200G TT w/ Ortofon Jubilee MC cart
ZMC1
ZP3 (25th A Mods)
ZR2 (25th A Mods)
CSP3 (25th A mods)
ZMA (25th A mods)
HR1s (Upgrd - top & bass drivers & X-ovr)
Silver Cabling
DIY Isolation platforms under everything.
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #54 - 06/16/19 at 12:20:43
 
Just for fun I decided to add the original 2000 uF Red capacitors for a total of 13500 uF per side. As a quic experiment I did the connections with alligator clips as shown in the picture.

Folks if you doubt music with such a drastic change from the humble beginnings of only 2000 uF per side has no effect, you are mistaken. You’ll think your ears have undergone a tune up – everything is even more crisp and clean.

Background is getting blacker more and more as there is now lesser and lesser dependence on the electrical grid for immediate power gratification. This background thing b.t.w. is not fathomable. Until it is moved further down you realize there is this lower level. Every time it is lowered the sound becomes more and more clear like more and more shine is being produced by constant buffing on chrome metal.

I probably reached the limit of these input transformers' start up current. I could hear the electrical flux building up in the transformers when I toggled the power switch to "ON". However running current through the input transformers seems to be lower based on the running temperature of the transformers being 10F lower than normal – 99 F vs 110F. However I have been only running like this for an hour now. I’ll take more readings further along and report here if the temperature drastically increases.
Back to top
 

IMG_20190613_200454.gif
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #55 - 06/23/19 at 18:58:41
 
Something huge in the works.

My drive to achieve more and more perfection or OCD in modern parlance has compelled me to place an order for input and output transformers made by the same manufacture as the original ones  on the ZMA but of substantially higher output.

Rationale:

My calculations and discussion with the manufacturer of the transformers viz. Hammond Manufacturing have led me to believe if driving higher wattage, lower efficiency wide frequency speakers the original transformers are close to their "core saturation" point at mid/high volumes levels. Definitely using KT88 tubes at higher outputs will exceed the manufactures specs for the transformers (even though the ZMA owners manual has listed KT88 as an alternate) entering the region of saturation of the transformer core. BTW the stock ZMA will easily drive speakers that are 90 dB or more efficient and that do not go lower than say 30 Hz or so. In this case these and all earlier posted upgrades will yield proportionally less results as the speaker demands on the amp are far less.

Thing is these new transformers are physically larger in size,I have no idea how I am going to fit them on the amplifier base. As with all the upgrades done so far if things do not work I have the option of going back.

While I am at it I decided to include a filtering section so also ordered a couple of 5H chokes and 47 uF Mundorf Tube caps. These definitely will have to be external to the ZMA base unit.

Both looking forward to it as well as not for the amount of work involved. Might be far more than I have done so far for any single upgrade task. To gain access to shoulder points I expect to remove a lot of the work already done and re-fixing it all back.

No rest for the wicked ...
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #56 - 06/29/19 at 02:33:11
 
Transformers, reactors and capacitors have arrived. No turning back now.

Not looking forward to the work involved which I figure will be far in excess of anything I have done on the ZMA so far. As they say "No pain, no gain"

The transformers are about 25% larger and heavier and will not fit on the ZMA base so will have to think of something which usually means much more work than usual on account of the trail and error this entails.

The picture shows the new transformers. I'll try to post another one showing the size difference side by side after I remove the old ones.
Back to top
 

IMG_20190621_175859.gif
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #57 - 07/04/19 at 02:48:46
 
The new input transformers are about 30% larger and weigh a ton. Original ones are rated at 150 VA and 173 mA while the corresponding figures for the new ones that I am installing are 243 VA, 288 mA.

The new output transformers are rated for 60 W v/s 40 W.

So size is a head spinner for this upgrade. See photo. The new one is to the left and the old removed input transformer is to the right. This was a case of getting the transformers of the power rating I wanted and thinking of how to fit them on the fly. There is very little excess real estate on the ZMA base to accommodate the new input transformers. The output transformers are only slightly larger, it looks like they are going to fit. Physical size must have been a consideration when Steve chose the transformers that he did. I feel especially the input transformer could have be higher rated, but 372 FX is the largest 600V transformer in the Hammond's line up that will fit on the ZMA base. The model I am installing is the 372 JX.

Can't wait to finish this project, only about 20 % done so far. If the original transformers are underpowered for my 99 dB, 300 W speakers than this upgrade will make a substantial difference on the other hand if they are not underpowered than the difference in sound quality will not be as much if any.
Back to top
 

IMG_20190625_174440.gif
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #58 - 07/11/19 at 02:40:18
 
Done, done and done.

Just powered up after completing the mods mentioned in the two posts just above. I am exhilarated both with the outcome and even more importantly because things largely went to plan. It actually works! And works it does. Only blew the fuse once during the test phase on the work bench (kitchen table) because I missed insulating a wire with shrink tubing. Considering that that was the only mistake after working on about 60 to 70 close quarter and sometimes inaccessible soldering points I am happy with myself. I had to celebrate the occasion by myself alone with a single malt and the evening off just listening to my now much elevated music. By myself because as while the wife saw me toiling away for days on end she did not seem to appreciate the work done or how things could have gone wrong. Importantly we are both happy to have music back and back with a bang.

I will come back with details and pictures. Could not wait to post the good news.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Jeff of Arabica
Seasoned Member
****


Name the greatest of
all inventors...
Accident.

Posts: 818
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #59 - 07/11/19 at 05:17:58
 
Bonny, impressed in an understatement!  You are my DIY hero brother!  

I have been following your journey the whole time.  Far have you come since our original collaboration on some of our early ZMA modifications.  You have taken the ball and ran 1000 yards beyond the point I reached with my modifications.  I am envious of the transformer upgrade as that was an area I researched tremendously but the fell short as the transformers I wanted to install would not fit on the plate.  Plus, that was a soldering venture I had not the time  or patience to commit.  

Your post hit home as there were many times during my upgrade process where I was up to my ass and elbows in work on my dining room table convincing my wife that it was all worth it.  While she may not truly grasp the ROI on the improvements, the time, money, and effort were ABSOLUTELY worth it.  My ZMA is Divine.  But.........   there is no doubt in my mind that it can't hold a candle to yours.  

That said, congratulations my friend and a fine single malt is such an appropriate way to reward yourself for enduring.  Bravo!  I might need to invite myself to your house when I am in your neck of the woods to have a listen.  Based on what I know and what you have done, it would be well worth the effort.  

Cheers,
Jeff
Back to top
 
 

ZMA//Zen Ultra//Rachel//Super Zen//Taboo MKIII//PS Audio DirectStream DAC + Memory Player + P10//Muse Phono Stage//London Decca Reference//Dynavector DV-507 MKII//Zen Head//SonoruS Reel-to-Reel w/ tube playback pre-amp//Omega SAHOs//DM946//Oppo UDP-205
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #60 - 07/11/19 at 22:00:20
 
Jeff, you are welcome buddy. If ever you are in the Toronto area be sure to give me a buzz. It will be my pleasure to have you listen to my system. This invitation is also to any one on the forum including the guru Steve.

In a sense you and Vyokyong were the brave ones that got me taking the first steps. I was initially hesitant to void the warranty. Then you made a statement somewhere on this forum that for you audio quality in the present trumps all else (e.g. longevity, warranty etc. etc) which struck a cord in me, being of the same mindset in the first place. No point in living with less quality of a longer duration even if say component life is shorter or the warranty is voided if it is within your means to improve things. Also these point to point wired amps are built like a tank and quite easily repaired unlike solid state amps.

Cheers to you as well. Have one on my behalf while enjoying your system.

Bonny
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Steve Deckert
Administrator
*****


If the 1st watt
sucks why continue?

Posts: 3804
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #61 - 07/13/19 at 00:21:50
 

Mostly we should all congratulate you for still being alive with all the microfarads.  Also congratulations you've just built yourself a pair of TORII Monos : )

I'm tipping a beer to you right now.

Steve
Back to top
 
 
WWW   IP Logged
Jeff of Arabica
Seasoned Member
****


Name the greatest of
all inventors...
Accident.

Posts: 818
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #62 - 07/13/19 at 03:24:43
 
What amazes me....   this 40 watt ZMA is powering my Essence Audio Amethyst 10A Reference speakers beautifully.  Volume is more than sufficient, about 85% output and no clipping for a listening level beyond conversational.  Soundstage is wide...  reaching 180 degrees with ease.  Bass is beautiful and holds it own amidst the midrange and treble prowess of this speaker stack.  

These speakers weigh in at 90dB efficiency, 10 separate drivers from the 12" bass drivers to super tweeters, the ZMA ain't intimidated and taking no $h!% from this formidable speaker system.  

Back to top
 
 

ZMA//Zen Ultra//Rachel//Super Zen//Taboo MKIII//PS Audio DirectStream DAC + Memory Player + P10//Muse Phono Stage//London Decca Reference//Dynavector DV-507 MKII//Zen Head//SonoruS Reel-to-Reel w/ tube playback pre-amp//Omega SAHOs//DM946//Oppo UDP-205
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #63 - 07/13/19 at 05:09:05
 
I feel honored Steve.

You brought up a good safety point. I should have mentioned about the dangers of working with such high power reserves, just to put it out there. Normally I do as when I mentioned of the dangers when experimenting 8 gauge wire in place of the fuse, because I breath and live safety as I work for a reputed electric power generation company that supplies power at 500,000 V to the Ontario and by extension to the North East American electric grid. Looking back I got caught up with the single minded purpose of improving SQ so missed mentioning the safety aspects.

After the upgrade work and testing is done and once assembled with all raw contacts inside or insulated if exposed outside as in my case it should be safe for operation.

The effects of so much capacitance though is just giddy and needs to be experienced.

I must also humbly confess I learned a lot from you – directly from your white papers and posts but for the detail technical aspects indirectly by passively studying your amps at great length. While I have experience in electrical equipment and parts such as capacitors, resistors, diodes, rectifiers, solenoids, motors, generators etc. in many other different applications, I did not until a few years ago have much experience in audio circuitry and have used your amps to self study your designs. There are times I believe I read your mind through your designs and figured out why you chose a particular path or component quality or size.

This is the only forum I am active on as I find it to be an environment that checks all the right boxes for an open discussion designed to elevate each others audio experience and is the reason I decided to spend bit of my time chronicling my experiences to give back to you and others in this audio community.

Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #64 - 07/13/19 at 05:35:38
 
Wow, Jeff those speakers take the cake.

Do they have active crossovers? If so that could be the reason the ZMA is able to drive them sufficiently.

If not, I am dumb founded.

In either case it might be interesting to experiment with bi-amping them. Good as things are now, I feel you could possibly scale dizzying heights. Even though they sound good as is with the ZMA alone, it's possible that the drivers will respond even better with more power that bi-amping would entail. I won’t be surprised if the timing and leading and trailing edges extend even more than now.

Cheers,

Bonny
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Jeff of Arabica
Seasoned Member
****


Name the greatest of
all inventors...
Accident.

Posts: 818
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #65 - 07/13/19 at 05:57:16
 
Hi Bonny,
No active crossovers.  The drivers are 90dB so in the transmission line cabinets they are probably closer to 92dB.  Anyway, they are nott what I would consider high efficiency drivers and there are 10 of them!

The ZMA is handling them like a champ!  I am a proud father  :)

But, my ZMA got drafted after my Canary Audio monblocks went in for a major overhaul/upgrade.  My ZMA's are assigned to my Hegeman Model 1A's, but called to duty these past couple months as I wait for the Canary "Reference Two" mondoblocks to come back.  They are 300B based 80W monoblocks that are being upgraded to the new flagship, "Grand Reference" model.  

I definitely think that bi-amping could be a good option.  I am hesitant to bi-amp with different amps and these Grand References are cost prohibitive to obtain a second pair.  They retail for $42K.  

A ZMA tri-amp setup would be something I could get excited about!  
Back to top
 
 

ZMA//Zen Ultra//Rachel//Super Zen//Taboo MKIII//PS Audio DirectStream DAC + Memory Player + P10//Muse Phono Stage//London Decca Reference//Dynavector DV-507 MKII//Zen Head//SonoruS Reel-to-Reel w/ tube playback pre-amp//Omega SAHOs//DM946//Oppo UDP-205
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #66 - 07/13/19 at 13:54:53
 
Jeff you stole my thunder. Just kidding I am happy for you. I just checked the specifications of Canary Audio Grand Reference two monoblocs: 16 of 300B tubes in parallel push pull arrangement! These itself will cost more than a very good tube amp and +/- 1 dB from 8 Hz to 80,000 Hz really! You really need those super tweeters and the 12 inch woofers to utilize the wide audio spectrum these amps are capable of. You are on another planet buddy.

BTW Parts Connexion has an almost new PS Audio P20 on sale. Just saying it would do a system like yours a world of good instead of the P10. I have bought a lot of parts from them and am in touch with the owner Chris and could try to get you an even better price for you.

Given this new revelation from you I think you will be disappointed with my set up. It is I who will benefit from having a listen to your system.

Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #67 - 07/13/19 at 23:11:14
 
Time for some pictures of the development process.

This one shows the mod done on the right side with the old set up on the left all powered up and playing music. I decided to test it at this midway stage to enable me to discern the difference between the new and the old setup by listening to the difference on the right v/s the left channel.

Conclusion: the right channel was significantly less labored with the mid-range and woofers benefiting tremendously. More audio information on the right channel compared to the left.

It might be hard to tell from the pictures but the right set of tubes were more brightly lit than the left ones.
Back to top
 

IMG_20190629_205523.gif
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #68 - 07/13/19 at 23:17:42
 
This one shows the temperature measured on the right channel new input transformer exterior surface. Quite a bit lower than the that of the old left channel 38C v/s 51C. The next post shows the temperature on the left channel old transformer.

My solution to install the new larger input transformer was to install it on 5 inch stand off's. This allowed for over hang above the speaker binding post. The larger new transformers would not fit in the smaller space.

Turned out there were additional benefits to being placed up and away. The left updated channel was eerily quite when music was not being played as compared to the old unmodified left channel. Could be because of the inevitable leakage flux out of the transformer core was now not affecting the speaker binding posts. In the old arrangement the speaker binding post were less than half an inch away from the transformer. Also now the new input transformer being up and away there is no (or less) coupling of the leakage fluxes of the input and output transformers allowing each to function more independently without interference on each other. Steve oriented the input and output transformers at 90 degrees to each other so as to minimize the interference of the two fluxes. In the new arrangement it went a step beyond they are not only at right angles to each other but also physically apart. Because flux density decreases significantly with distance it is more effective in reducing the influence.

The down side of having the input transformer - which is the heaviest of the lot - higher is that it raises the center of gravity of the amp as a whole making transporting it by carrying it more tricky. It was by chance that this is my last mod so I do not now have to move it much if at all.
Back to top
 

IMG_20190629_213650.gif
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #69 - 07/13/19 at 23:19:25
 
Picture of the temperature of the left old input transformer.
Back to top
 

IMG_20190629_213700.gif
  IP Logged
Archie
Seasoned Member
****




Posts: 1417
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #70 - 07/14/19 at 00:05:52
 
If the tubes are brighter, are they being pushed harder?  (at the same bias I assume)
Back to top
 
 

Technics 1200G TT w/ Ortofon Jubilee MC cart
ZMC1
ZP3 (25th A Mods)
ZR2 (25th A Mods)
CSP3 (25th A mods)
ZMA (25th A mods)
HR1s (Upgrd - top & bass drivers & X-ovr)
Silver Cabling
DIY Isolation platforms under everything.
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #71 - 07/14/19 at 01:00:41
 
Good question.

It is the filament voltage that will affect the brightness of the tubes. So bias can be anything: low or high the brightness should not be affected unless biased way I mean way out of the allowable range which no one is going to do. Even than I think the brightness change will not be such as to be discernible (I think, I have not tried it nor do I want to).

So since we are talking of filament voltage and current a good way to look at it would be a normal old fashioned filament bulb in a house hold circuit. A 100 W bulb will consume 100W if given its designed voltage which in north America is 120V is maintained. Given that the voltage is fixed the current consumed by the bulb will be defined by the resistance of the filament in the bulb - which is also fixed. Now suppose one was to load that same circuit in the house on which this bulb is by adding other loads say a turning on an electric heater and other stuff the bulb will continue to be lit with the same brightness only if the supply can keep up with this extra load. If the supply is weak the bulb will dim as there is a drop in circuit voltage.

Similarly in an amp if the input transformer power rating is lowish such that its core is overfluxed or close to being overfluxed it will not keep up with the load demands of the various loads within the amp that rely on the input transformer and the brightness of the filaments - which is one of the loads - will be lowered and the behavior of the other things in that circuit will be affected. If say the original transformer was of substantially higher VI rating by my installing an even higher rated transformer will not increase the tube brightness as the load which is the tube will not consumer any more power than it's design. That would be a waste of money and time.

So what I am trying to say in this long winded explanation is that one can only suppress a load's (e.g tube) output and that it will not consume more power than its rated design. So by increasing the input transformers rating I have ensured that the filaments are being supplied by adequate enough power to operate the circuit components upto and no higher than design rating i.e. there is no suppression of that components output due to a paucity of power supply.

So yes the tubes are pushed harder but up to their rated design level. I am sure you are aware that it is the filaments that supply the electrons (indirectly by heating the cathode) that flow to the plate and the tube grids than control the flow to the plate to modulate the sound to match that of the music. So a copious supply of electrons will ensure that ease of producing music. Lack of supply electrons will take away portions of the music.

I hope the message is not lost in this long explanation: in short yes the tubes are driven harder but to their design rating which I like. Why have a race car and use it as a street car (if allowed) just to ensure longitivity.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Archie
Seasoned Member
****




Posts: 1417
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #72 - 07/14/19 at 01:14:34
 
If I supply more than the spec'd 120V to a 100W light bulb it will burn brighter (and have a shorter life) than at the spec'd 120V supply.

I take it that you haven't increased the voltage the tubes see?  I have nowhere near the understanding of how this all works that you do, I'm just curious about the increased brightness.  Are saying that the stock configuration doesn't fully utilize the design potential of the tubes.  I do remember reading for several different Decware amps that Steve intentionally doesn't push certain tubes very hard.

I've never noticed a fluctuation in my ZMA tube brightness while idling or playing.  I don't know how this relates, if at all.

Your modifications have made me even more curious to hear Steve's big monos.  They were never a consideration due to cost but my upgraded ZMA is already well past the halfway mark -- if I'd only known then what I know now!
Back to top
 
 

Technics 1200G TT w/ Ortofon Jubilee MC cart
ZMC1
ZP3 (25th A Mods)
ZR2 (25th A Mods)
CSP3 (25th A mods)
ZMA (25th A mods)
HR1s (Upgrd - top & bass drivers & X-ovr)
Silver Cabling
DIY Isolation platforms under everything.
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #73 - 07/14/19 at 02:42:26
 
To continue the analogy I am not upping the voltage to above 120V to cause the 100W bulb to burn brighter. I am bringing it to 120V i.e. bringing the filament voltage to the rated 6.3V under load conditions where as it appears the old transformers were loaded so much as to suppress the voltage hence dimmer tubes. In my case they are brighter because it is brought up to spec.

Yes it does appear Steve likes to design his stuff with longitivity in mind. Hence for the pre-amps such as the CSP3 he has deliberately staved the filament voltage supply ensuring longer than design life for the tubes and the components in the amp. In the case of the ZMA though I suspect it is because of space constraints. The physical size of the higher rated transformer caused the move to the current one. Only Steve will know the exact reason. In any case it fits his preference towards longitivity.

For him it is a balancing act getting the best bang for the buck in terms of longitivy only versus performance only criteria. As for me I am not constrained by the requirements imposed by others e.g. long life as I am doing it for myself and my personal bias is whole heartedly towards performance.

Mind you I do not over load anything beyond design but to design. So the life of my upgrades will still yield 20 years of operation. If I could get further performance improvement and it meant a life span of the equipment of 10 years I would still be happy. But going beyond design rating usually bring other undesirable artifacts into play so I like to stick to design knowing fully that the design specifications for industrial equipment (may not apply to audio equipment as it seems to be a free for all approach i.e. no national or international standards) is still conservative.

It does not appeal to me that I am using my equipment sub-optimally for 30 years when I can use it optimally for 20 years.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Archie
Seasoned Member
****




Posts: 1417
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #74 - 07/14/19 at 17:26:26
 
That makes sense.  Due to my limited knowledge ... do I not see a change in my tube glow between idle and full bore since these amps draw full power even at idle?  Am I confusing wall current with something else?  Since the transformers seem to stay the same temperature either way, I may have answered my own question.
Back to top
 
 

Technics 1200G TT w/ Ortofon Jubilee MC cart
ZMC1
ZP3 (25th A Mods)
ZR2 (25th A Mods)
CSP3 (25th A mods)
ZMA (25th A mods)
HR1s (Upgrd - top & bass drivers & X-ovr)
Silver Cabling
DIY Isolation platforms under everything.
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #75 - 07/14/19 at 18:41:19
 
My statement in my earlier post needs elaboration as it is not so cut and dry. I said "It does not appeal to me that I am using my equipment sub-optimally for 30 years when I can use it optimally for 20 years"

I would not fret too much either way as I think Steve has found the right balance for him to give the lifetime warranty while maintaining very good performance.

Unfortunately in life one can't have everything, there are compromises: in this case a conservative design approach for long life warranty or a absolute performance driven approach not caring if it involves more maintenance along the way.

Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #76 - 07/14/19 at 18:52:14
 
The tube glow should not change from 0W output to 40W (full load) of reasons I mentioned earlier, but the transformer temperatures should increase from no load to full load (40W). It will take some time for the temperature to manifest and stabilize to the full load level on the exterior of the input transformer as there is a lot of thermal inertia within the iron and copper masses of the transformers. After all the 40W plus losses (hysteresis and eddy currents losses increase in the transformer laminated core as current in the transformer coil increases) in the laminated iron core at full load are ultimately coming from the source.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #77 - 07/14/19 at 19:39:58
 
My high tech test bench.
Back to top
 

IMG_20190706_004334.gif
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #78 - 07/14/19 at 19:45:42
 
A close up picture of ZMA inverted and loaded on the test bench (kitchen table) to enable taking measurements. I used my home theater speakers - portions of which can be seen - to present a load to the ZMA as they were easier to carry to the "test bench".
Back to top
 

IMG_20190706_093708_001.gif
  IP Logged
Archie
Seasoned Member
****




Posts: 1417
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #79 - 07/14/19 at 19:46:32
 
At what point will you just bite the bullet and get a bigger plate?
Back to top
 
 

Technics 1200G TT w/ Ortofon Jubilee MC cart
ZMC1
ZP3 (25th A Mods)
ZR2 (25th A Mods)
CSP3 (25th A mods)
ZMA (25th A mods)
HR1s (Upgrd - top & bass drivers & X-ovr)
Silver Cabling
DIY Isolation platforms under everything.
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #80 - 07/14/19 at 20:05:17
 
No more upgrades. Done, done and done. Time to sit back and enjoy. Also every body at home is literally tired of seeing my face buried in the insides of this amp.

Aside from the obvious performance gains. This was a fun learning exercise, always pushing the limits just enough to stay out of trouble.  got to put my non-audio technical experience to use. Most of the knowledge is transportable from one field to the other and so I am richer in the other fields as well due to this project. Audio is unique as there are no national codes or standards so I have learnt a lot from first hand experience as to what works and what does not. I find there is more "hoopla" in the audio field than any other field. I'll share the lessons learnt in the coming days as I am sure there is take aways for everybody.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
Jeff of Arabica
Seasoned Member
****


Name the greatest of
all inventors...
Accident.

Posts: 818
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #81 - 07/14/19 at 21:01:07
 
Bonny, your pictures bring back memories...  My journey was pretty fun and very educational too, but I would be lying if I said there were no moments where expletives were blurted and tools thrown.  It was intense at times but once done, all that much more satisfying.  You made me laugh with your comments about the family and having your face implanted in the underside of the amplifier.  That, I can relate to.  

This ZMA is a great amp stock.  With the upgrades we have done (especially yours) it is a greater amp.  And despite having my crazy Canary monoblocks, I still love the sound of this amp!  While a very different experience with the ZMA in comparison, there are things I like about each and enjoy listening to them both with the different speakers I have in my stable.  

Do you have a pic you can send of the finished amp?
Back to top
 
 

ZMA//Zen Ultra//Rachel//Super Zen//Taboo MKIII//PS Audio DirectStream DAC + Memory Player + P10//Muse Phono Stage//London Decca Reference//Dynavector DV-507 MKII//Zen Head//SonoruS Reel-to-Reel w/ tube playback pre-amp//Omega SAHOs//DM946//Oppo UDP-205
  IP Logged
JD
Seasoned Member
****




Posts: 504
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #82 - 07/14/19 at 22:14:13
 
Congrats on being successful. Time to enjoy all of that hard work, well done.
JD
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #83 - 07/14/19 at 22:38:52
 
This picture is a good example for why my folks were tired of it all, cannot blame them. The whole kitchen table and surrounding area was taken over.

Note: I would evacuate everything after every 2 to 3 hour work phase for the day. Not an easy task with those now unbalanced heavy transformers.
Back to top
 

IMG_20190706_093729.gif
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #84 - 07/14/19 at 22:50:52
 
This is the photo of it all boxed back and up and running.
Back to top
 

IMG_20190714_174337.gif
  IP Logged
Archie
Seasoned Member
****




Posts: 1417
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #85 - 07/14/19 at 23:03:10
 
I think I can see a bulge in the case!   Grin
Back to top
 
 

Technics 1200G TT w/ Ortofon Jubilee MC cart
ZMC1
ZP3 (25th A Mods)
ZR2 (25th A Mods)
CSP3 (25th A mods)
ZMA (25th A mods)
HR1s (Upgrd - top & bass drivers & X-ovr)
Silver Cabling
DIY Isolation platforms under everything.
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #86 - 07/14/19 at 23:13:13
 
And this one is of the extensive power filter network comprising of 6 different values of capacitors, the smaller of which are located inside the amp and the two larger ones are on the outside seen here nicely hidden behind the amp not seen from the front along with the massive 5H chocks. Total power capacitance is 13500 uF per side for total of 27000 uF for the amp. After power off the amp stays on for a full 19 seconds now!

Note: as Steve said there a lot of reserve power in those capacitors even after power off. Here they are locate at the back inaccessible to anyone so I have not insulated the leads.

My system is so quiet now you can touch -I mean touch- your ear to the drivers and they are dead silent when no music is being played.

This level of quietness really makes a difference for the ability to hear very fine detail. If there is a buzz/hiss, even a slight one from say an inch from the drivers, when no music is playing and you cannot hear the buzz when music is being played it means that the buzz frequencies are either accentuating, nullifying or mitigating certain actual music frequencies - depending on the where the troughs or peaks of the buzz/hiss frequencies are w.r.t that of music frequencies thus causing the music to deviate however small from the original recording and the actual buzz to be not heard.
Back to top
 

IMG_20190706_111200.gif
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #87 - 07/14/19 at 23:23:42
 
Jeff, did you mean the above finished pictures or a close up of the internals after finishing it all?

Also did you also mean send to you by PM or post here?
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #88 - 07/14/19 at 23:37:08
 
Thanks JD.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
HockessinKid
Seasoned Member
****




Posts: 281
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #89 - 07/14/19 at 23:46:43
 
Very cool modifications to the ZMA Bonny. Way to take it to the max, then beyond.

What's next? Maybe a new exotic wood base?

HK
Back to top
 
 

Lonely Raven PC (or) TEAC PD-600H > ZDAC2 (or) Nottingham Interspace (heavy platter) TT w/ Dynavector 20x2 LO cart + P75 MKII phono pre > ZROCK2-25th > CSP3-25th preamp > Zen Mystery 25th amp > Omega SAHO XRS speakers > ZenWave Audio, TWL, & Acoustic BBQ cables.
  IP Logged
BAndrade
Senior Member
***


Do it once, do it
right. Repeat for
quality life.

Posts: 88
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #90 - 07/15/19 at 00:20:17
 
Thanks HK.

There is nothing else on the cards.

How did your 25th anniversary mods go? I remember you asking about WBT silver binding post and RCAs and the Furutech IEC connector. How did it work out?

Note if you did not hear additional finer details it could be because other things in the entire audio chain from source to speakers including the internals in each of the equipment (say fuses etc.) are limiting those mods. One's system is defined by the weakest point in the whole chain. It is the weakest (limiting) factor in the audio chain that you ultimately hear no matter how high grade all your other components are. Unfortunately that is the way it is. This is an expensive hobby.
Back to top
 
 
  IP Logged
HockessinKid
Seasoned Member
****




Posts: 281
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #91 - 07/15/19 at 00:46:29
 
Bonny,

My ZMA with limited mods done by Steve sound great. Thanks to your suggestions, Parts Connexion's WBT sale, and the 25th Anniversary mods the amp has been taken to a another level.

The only weak link I had was an aging stylus on my Dynavector 20x2 low output cartridge. Now that it's been retipped it's game on. My Ray Brown Soular Energy album pressing (Pure Audiophile label) absolutely blew my mind this morning. Everything, including CD's and TIDAL streaming just sounds amazing. Enjoy.

HK
Back to top
 
 

Lonely Raven PC (or) TEAC PD-600H > ZDAC2 (or) Nottingham Interspace (heavy platter) TT w/ Dynavector 20x2 LO cart + P75 MKII phono pre > ZROCK2-25th > CSP3-25th preamp > Zen Mystery 25th amp > Omega SAHO XRS speakers > ZenWave Audio, TWL, & Acoustic BBQ cables.
  IP Logged
Jeff of Arabica
Seasoned Member
****


Name the greatest of
all inventors...
Accident.

Posts: 818
Re: ZMA - comperhensive upgrade complete
Reply #92 - 07/15/19 at 00:48:38
 
Perfect Bonny!  That’s what I was looking for.

Your table looked like mine. My wife walked in one day and literally said, “Mother of God!!”
Back to top
 
 

ZMA//Zen Ultra//Rachel//Super Zen//Taboo MKIII//PS Audio DirectStream DAC + Memory Player + P10//Muse Phono Stage//London Decca Reference//Dynavector DV-507 MKII//Zen Head//SonoruS Reel-to-Reel w/ tube playback pre-amp//Omega SAHOs//DM946//Oppo UDP-205
  IP Logged
Pages: 1 2 
Send Topic Print