Forums
http://www.decware.com/cgi-bin/yabb22/YaBB.pl
OLDER DECWARE GEAR SUPPORT >> SE84A, SE84B, SE84C, SE84C+,SE84CKC >> The genius of the SE84 amp design.
http://www.decware.com/cgi-bin/yabb22/YaBB.pl?num=1209112208

Message started by Terry on 04/25/08 at 09:30:07

Title: The genius of the SE84 amp design.
Post by Terry on 04/25/08 at 09:30:07


Here we are ten years after the birth of the SE84A and this amp is more than still around but doing well.  After getting into designing of tube amps I soon came to realize some of the less well known features of this amplifier.  So I thought I would start a thread on some of the technical circuit aspects of the amp that I feel account for why it works so well.  Steve if he feels inclined can jump in here as well.  I am going to number them so as to make responses easier for others.

1)  The output transformers  This one feature accounts for so much of the amplifiers fidelity, it is an enigma as to why they have been criticized so much.  Of course you can obtain better OPT's, but at a cost of more than the entire amplifier it really doesn't make a lot of sense.  What most of the critics are against are the very things that make these stock OPT's work so well.  You have to look at the symbiotic nature of the entire amplifier.  The higher impedance of the OPT's primary accomplishes some very note worthy things, greater power supply ripple rejection, less of a load on the tube which increases the gain of the circuit slightly, the power supply can then be made ultra fast which increases transient current delivery making for a fast airy sound.  Then if you use low impedance speakers (with a benine impedance plot) you can lower distortion and the combination is killer good at ultra low cost.  Coupled with this is a very gradual sloping frequency response on the bottom end that makes the best use of the available 2 watts.  The synergy of this circuit design with this tube is nothing short of genius, if you listened to 50 different combinations of operating points with different OPT's i am sure that blind listening tests would put you with this combination every time.  That is of course if you like the open airy detailed high resolution sound that is the base of the imaging character of the SE84 series of amplifiers.

2)  Metal film resisters  Steve usually uses metal film resisters, these sound pretty neutral and allow a lot of detail through, especially in the grid stopper position.   Some other types of resistors have more noise, so these are a good inexpensive resistor with a big bang for the buck.  Non-inductive wire-wounds like the ones that can be found in the PS are also very good.  Carbon comps should be used carefully, as they are very noisy, but sometimes you need to use them with high gain circuits.  But if you use metal film resistors you need to use better quality caps.

3) Metalised film caps Here is another good choice in the SE84 amp, they more transparent than than electrolytics, and some other types of caps,  the original SE84's used Solen fast caps, but it looks like above that Steve is also using GE Metalised caps which are also good.  One upgrade many have tried is to replace the cap off of the first stages plate with a teflon V-cap, which takes the amp to a whole new level after breakin for a very effortless sound.


Many have tried to copy the Decware SE84 amp, but none have really done it successfully, as the synergy of the above is part of what I feel makes it work so well.  There are of course some upgrades you can make to the amp, but the basic design is what makes it work so well.


TG

 

Title: Re: The genius of the SE84 amp design.
Post by buzz on 05/05/08 at 09:07:35

Terry,

Another point to add to the 'genius' of the amp is its marketing...

At the time of it's original release there were few modern tube amplifiers available, and none that were affordable. The icing on the cake was that Steve released the SCHEMATIC. This did several things IMO. For instance... it showed the designers confidence, his support of DIY, and that there was nothing to hide. Also, each 'clone' amp that was built was (is) an expression of the adage "imitation is the sincerest form of flattery" and were advertising themselves. People knew that if clones sounded better than anything they had heard before, then an authentic Decware SE84 must sound even better. For the reasons you mentioned above, they do. :)

Timing is everything... Internet + Decware = Pivotal moment in audio history.

buzz

Title: Re: The genius of the SE84 amp design.
Post by Lon on 05/14/08 at 02:45:46

Good points Guys!

Remember though there were about thirty amps that were not "A" before revision A.

I've had three Decware amps, one before revision A that became a revision A, a Select and my current pair of E34L Monoblocks.  Incredible value and years of enjoyment.  

Title: Re: The genius of the SE84 amp design.
Post by Terry on 05/17/08 at 15:11:47

Lon,

Do you remember the differences of the amps from the original to the A revision?  As I recall the A version was still a pentode amp with triode option by means of the little switch and the B revision dropped the pentode switch for bias adjustment on the input tube.

Terry

Title: Re: The genius of the SE84 amp design.
Post by Lon on 05/17/08 at 21:44:37

The Revision that was A was a change to allow SV83s and 6N1P

Title: Re: The genius of the SE84 amp design.
Post by stone_of_tone on 06/10/08 at 16:54:31

What a great Thread.  I have enjoyed this hobby for 24 years and have had a dedicated Listening Room for 13 years.  The Zen CS was added to the below in May of 2001 and it still NEVER ceases to amaze me with its Musicality!  I love the SV83 (6n15nM) tube best. I have 3 other Good Systems in my house. None can rival the Transparency/Genius of Mr. Deckerts Amp.  You always want to hear just one more song.  Pick your illusion of the event taking place around you - the SE84CS is certainly mine.

Stone of Tone

Forums » Powered by YaBB 2.2.2!
YaBB © 2000-2008. All Rights Reserved.